Next to the central yarhnam lamp is the window that you HAVE to talk to in order to progress. How am I supposed to know that this ordinary window and lamp is required to progress? Nothing about it really stands out. Maybe experienced bloodborne players know about this window and talk to it at the start of their runs but I am not one of them.
Also please let us rebind controls for accessibility and to not mess with muscle memory (I attack with circle and roll with R2 normally)
Not criticizing this since you want it to be original to games of this era and that's what you're used to but the old school controls were frustrating and is one of the reasons I quit acclaimed games of this era so I modern control scheme would be nice. The issues I mentioned made me quit bloodborne psx