Im guessing you chose the Kill Option on the Fat Rapist Pig yeah? I was more disappointed about that guy surviving vs Losing to the Hero.
The Hero part kind played out like Shield Hero when Raphtalia's slave contract was broken and He got angry, but this turns that around and instead we got the Bummed out MC who didnt win on Purpose because he has already had it in mind to break the Slave Contract. So its a Win for MC and Loss for Hero. Just makes the Hero look like a Doofus and Douche bag in front of the Female Hero.