I started off really enjoying this game, the way it was designed, the graphics, the world building, the models etc. However, towards the middle to end of the game It stopped being a horror game and instead felt a bit more like a chore to play. It became increasingly more annoying, as I stopped being as scared of Tinky since it was very predictable, but it was especially so with the ending. Its was just the same thing over and over again, which is to run across the insanely huge map and collect stuff (which usually isn't a problem but in this case it was just too long and repeated too many times).
The AI at the end was just completely weird, it would look straight ahead and somehow it would detect you even though you're on the side and not even in his flashlight view. It doesn't even matter whether or not he was looking at you or facing your way, or if you hide behind an object.
After you get detected, he just teleports to the end of the large map, and you have to slowly make your way over there as the stamina burns out really fast. If it wasn't for the fact that I've spent 1 hour already recording majority of the game I was going to call it quits as it just seemed impossible and too infuriating to beat this.
I haven't played the original that came out in 2012 but assuming that it is just a remake with updated graphics I wish they would've tried to cut out some unnecessary stuff out in order to just make the duration of the game more manageable. I finished the game confused and puzzled as the story didn't make much sense to me either.
This is just my opinion, but I don't recommend this game if you don't have a lot of patience or time as I had thought this was going to be a 30 - 50 minute game but it easily stretches over an hour to 2 hours depending on how good you are, which I hardly struggled in the beginning but somehow still managed to get a one hour 50 minute recording. (feel free to give it a shot of course but I'm warning you, the final fight is extremely difficult for no reason).
Overall I'd say that the graphics, world design, idea, and creativity behind the game is good but the game was stretched out too long.
Keep up the good work Devs