i finished the game. i will now hurt your feelings and tell you everything that i hated!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ok maybe not like that but... this game is littered with a bunch of little flaws. contains mild spoilers
(played on windows btw)
Art:
honestly, my only issue with the art is how the overworld and pixel art looked, and it mainly has to do with the environment and its colors. It feels like those colors are a bit saturated and bright, so it could use some toning down.
also why are amelias arms like that? her arms are longer on the back/front sprites than left/right. left/right makes her arms look short and stubby.
Music:
nothing wrong with the music, but just out of curiosity, may I ask why certain rooms have their own themes? Like it's funny how the staff room has a different theme than the staff lounge.
Story:
No real critique, but I feel like the characters are a little dumb for being detectives. like... "how could a random swimmer know that?" I kinda just sighed. This is information you can just look up on the internet. Especially with the fact that the game developer knows this information. These are people with brains and an access to knowledge!!!! The discrimination!!!!111!!!! Thankfully, Amelia recognized this, but jeez...
Gameplay/Bugs:
here's where the juice is. i seriously had to get a notepad to write down everything for this review. i swear i'm not a professional. Like take a look at my inconsistent capitalization during this entire thing.
Starting with the positives, i do like the main thing where you really have to pay attention to details in environment and dialogue and logic. it's gameplay inspired by ace attorney, i heard, but i never played that game so i have no idea how that game works so i wont be able to draw comparisons to it.
During the last "fight" (funny how they're called fights/battles) i felt like i didn't have the evidence I needed (i did) and I felt the need to abort out of the battle to explore a little more (worst mistake ever i ended up walking around the map painfully for a very long time.) I don't know if an abort option would be necessary in this game, but perhaps there should be one perchance.
There's ONE really really big and ANNOYING BUG at the last part of the game before the last fight. it's the one where everyone is in the storage room before they move to the lockers. When they move to the lockers, sometimes (a lot of the time) they will respawn BACK in the storage room AND OUT OF the locker room.
I believe it happens when you leave the storage room to the pool then go into another room, then back to the pool. This was a real pain in my ass. please fix this. this is by far the worst complaint in this review.
anyway last up, why were amelias suspects for the murderer her friends plus the lifeguard. that's just kinda strange.
Extra:
I honestly liked the previous name of this game "Graywood" better. iirc it got changed because it was already taken or something.
You sly dog!!!!! You really think you can add the god damn Yo Gurt joke in the game and think I wouldn't notice!!!!!!!!!! (it was pretty obvious you probably expected people to notice)
Conclusion:
Sorry if i seemed a bit mean. there's only so many positive things i can say about a game, and I don't want to sugarcoat anything. making a game is hard and sometimes you might think your game is ASS and someone ends up saying its ASS and it actually is ASS-(jk)
I've been kind of excited for this game to come out ever since I saw the devlogs on instagram. i really like and would love to support indie game devs. gamedev is cool.
I'm honestly anticipating the future of this game and what's to come. I'll be here when Act I releases.
bye













