Post by nobodymeep69 in Ilias: Alcyone legends comments - itch.io

Ilias: Alcyone legends » Comments

Viewing post in Ilias: Alcyone legends comments

← Return to game comments

nobodymeep69247 days ago (2 edits)

A hand on the big art on this page looks AI generated (wolf-lady in black dress). I'm not hugely against AI art, but...it is pretty jarring to see compared to the rest of the artwork. I still play games and look at AI art, but I think it should be clear if it is drawn or generated.

I get it if it's AI generated and then drawn. Maybe double check the review process?

I'll probably try the game later, best of luck!

Edit for clarification: Top, big picture. Lower left corner. Wolf girl with her hand on her hip/butt.

Alcyone legends247 days ago (1 edit) (+9)

WTF ?There are no AI generated drawings in the game

AnosRim245 days ago

I think that just means you're talented that you made it look like ai generated😂

Alcyone legends247 days ago(+4)

We even posted a free speedpaint of one scene, but we keep getting accused of AI...

https://www.patreon.com/posts/drawing-new-in-97906464

Here are PSD sources of scenes from the game -

https://www.patreon.com/collection/242388

nobodymeep69247 days ago

If there's multiple accusations of AI, there might be something causing it.

I can see it was rude of me to jump to AI. I think all the art looks beautiful. That's why it was jarring to me to see the lower left corner of the cover image on this page. It was an "Ayo? What's going on there?" moment for me personally.

Alcyone legends247 days ago(+3)

There are so many accusations of AI art use these days for no other reason than that, since some developers use it, people have begun to suspect absolutely everyone.
We are always open and honest about our work and we have never used AI for anything, anywhere. Our illustrator for this project is our art lead and game designer, the guy who sweats over and meticulously works out the narrative and setting of the game. He’s been drawing for over six years, and the whole saga of his growth as an artist is clearly recorded for all to see. What’s more, he continues to actively refine his skillset. Human beings can make minor mistakes with anatomy, shadows, etc., due to oversight or gaps in their knowledge. That’s a normal thing. It’s deeply upsetting for us to hear constant accusations of AI use being leveled at us simply because our wonderful artist happens to have a style that bears a cursory resemblance to certain AI art.

Justy311247 days ago(+2)

Honestly, kudos on not using AI, but even if you did it'd be fine. A game is about a lot more than just the art itself and the writing, character development, personalities, etc all matter as well. Anyone who'd snub a game just because it has AI generated art in it (which by the way takes time, effort, etc. on it's own to make it good.) clearly needs to take a step back. That's like watching only movies that have no CGI or digital special effects in them at all.

nobodymeep69247 days ago(+1)

Agreed, like I said, I'm playing some games with AI art and the game incorporates it into the atmosphere, setting, and story.

Taking Marvel movies...some of the CGI could have benefited from more time in the oven.

Alcyone legends246 days ago(+1)

I see your point, I didn't mean to hurt or offend you, I was just defending our artist's work! Have a good day!

nobodymeep69247 days ago(+1)

You are well within your rights to defend your artist and writers. I have to point out that being dedicated and talented does not exclude one from using AI. In some cases, it is because of the talent and hard work that people resort to help. Most notable example is the artist for a Dungeons and Dragons book. He drew and colored the art himself and used AI for a final filter and it left some noticable artifacts. Most people wouldn't touch steroids. Olympic athletes with fame, money, and drive for competition have more reason.

Alcyone legends246 days ago

Well said )

darebrained244 days ago(+1)

When I saw the artstyle I also had suspicions it might be AI generated; the fact that there is a credit section for voice work but no mention of an artist as far as I saw when skimming over it doesn't help that look.

Maybe just add credits for art and writing in addition to the voice work? That way people would know where to look.

Alcyone legends244 days ago

In the section about the game there is a mention of 2 of our artists... but that's probably the way to do it.

darebrained244 days ago

I mean I searched the page for "artist" and "illustra" (since just searching "art" was a bit too unspecific and gave too many results to effectively show something) and the first instance of artists being referenced was this chain of comments.

Alcyone legends244 days ago(+1)

https://twitter.com/ebakubaku - ArtLead