Deleted post
I found a bug when the game first came out, just hold left mouse click as soon the quick draw instructions ends/it fades to black (left click to end it, then hold left click) and you'll win every shoot out onwards (if you continue holding the left click, I don't think spacebar works for it)
Alternatively, you can just shoot the scarecrow and hold the left click for the rest of the game and that would also work.