I tried Gideon and Jagger but I still didn't get anything. Do I need to do anything specific?
The four pics you are referring to are only for having Ace as the main character. Pairing other characters will not get you these pics yet.
You have to play as Ace, like we said. <3 You would have to do a run, as Ace, picking all 4 different friends night 1, and then get to the night the scene in question occurs.
There will be different combos of chars and methods in the future, but right now, only Ace as a main character has access to these.
I am so sorry about the confusion—in addition to what we said, you also have to pick the tiger or the crocodile on Feb 14's decision. Otherwise, Ace's route will temporarily end (until future content is created)
The 14th decision is separate from your friend night 1. That should solve that now! My apologies. All 4 scenes are definitely possible tho, just play as Ace, pick different friends night 1, and pick either tiger or croc Feb 14 to unlock the different scenes w friends.