You need to hold the Tuna Fish in your inventory, that's what he wants, if you don't have it, then you're ded.
Oh, that makes sense. Also answers my question of what the fish was for lol. Thanks. Is there a cooldown time after you give him the fish until he wants another one?
yeah it depends sometimes it can take 30 seconds it really depends on the difficulty level tho
But it's better to use the conservative one, or it's really gonna kill you
This method works, it just needs you to be quick enough not to let it find you're moving.