Not really sure what happened, but I got the good ending with Quest and Nightowl and still can't access the Toast story. I have all of the bonus stuff that goes along with the good ending for both of the other characters, and was even following the guide for Toast, but it just funneled me into Nightowl's story?
Viewing post in ok i made the walkthroughs comments
Okay, so, I even tried using the username "LovelyLola" to try to force the Toast storyline and STILL got Nightowl. Not sure what to do at this point, I've even gone through and re-did both Quest and Nightowl's stories following the walkthrough for both of them word for word on a speedrun to try to get the Toast options to unlock, and it's not working. What am I doing wrong?