Great game! Short, but fun! Coming back to this after Elevator Hitch is interesting. I'm on a kick of your games recently, so I'm looking forward to experiencing them all.
((SPOILERS BELOW))
For me, the largest source of horror that came from the first ending in particular was the implication that Angelica + the fallen angel would have to live as the pastor's dead wife until Forcas can find a way to save them. Ah, to be forced to play the part of a dead woman who had a life that you know nothing about. And a restrictive looking one at that, if the whole emphasis on everything being "perfect" was any indication for that (trial or not, there's obviously something that's been wrong with this church for a while). Especially considering the pastor is alive, meaning this poor girl had to pretend to be his wife. Eugh. Though I suppose the real victim in all this is Angelica, since this wouldn't have happened if the fallen angel didn't tell the church that they could bring back the pastor's wife.