Confusing or misleading text is not a "puzzle".
Viewing post in STAY AWAY FROM THE LIGHTHOUSE comments
This isn't misleading. It's asking you a question without giving you enough information to know the answer. That's not fun, it's terrible puzzle design. With good puzzles, you provide the player with all of the information that they need to make the right decision, then you mislead them in a subtle but obvious way. That's fun.