Hey there!
Sorry to hear. Day 2 can be a bit tight (we may still open up an extra day or two). There is one soul that is very easy to miss that makes it easier. Mason will refuse to talk to you until you prove you can past Lazren's first test. After you do, he'll open up a bit about his backstory when you ask him. Learning all this info will set you on the path to get an extra gem from him after a few days.
Hopefully that gives you a little more breathing room if you try our game again!