I wouldn't mind having red hair and green eyes!
Of course, having chocolate skin like Lily is lovely.
And being able to get an island tan would be nice.
Maybe for new game+ mode you get "Island Eyes", those eyes all the insane/possessed islanders get?
Like the ones the Jail Break dude had when he grabbed & pulled you into the cell doors bars?
Like, if you unlock the "villainous" ending?
(Assuming such an ending ever happens, of course!)
LOL! If you get ALL the "Dead Ends" you can unlock a Zombie skin like the native dream boy.
"I look in the mirror and see my rotting corpse starring back at me with lifeless eyes crying tears of dried blood, but Lily insists that I look the same as ever. Have I gone mad? Or is this a nightmare? Did I die & go to hell? Is this a test of faith? BAH! It matters not at all for I must save my lil'sister!"