An important update:
It looks like most of the dummy accounts were deleted early this morning, and by pure coincidence Champion of Realms lost almost the EXACT amount of reviews.
I hesitated with naming who I suspected of committing this botting until I had definitive proof, but now we do.
My game reviews now:
*removed per admin request*
Champion of Realm's game reviews now:
Champion of Realm's game reviews yesterday afternoon sometime:
If this isn't clear and evident proof of review manipulation, I have no idea what else could be.
Itch.io would obviously have logs of all of this, making the act of deleting them not only useless, but actively stupid.
All they need to do is actually respond.