I called Nova "my friend" when she and the other girl ask you to judge, then went "truth", "dare", "Charlotte" (and didn't go to the lockerooms when Regina said I should), in case the key to reproducing it is in any of those variables! (I also went to Nova first, then choose "Not ready", checked on Penny, and then went do the challenges). I think that covers all my choices during the party segment, hope it helps!