Review, may contain spoilers
Wow. This game is genuinely a treasure. I am grateful to have stumbled upon it by chance and I dread to think of a reality where I did not click on it! Of course, I am grateful to the writer even more so for making this wonderful work.
I didn't expect to enjoy this game so much when I first started. I'm not normally drawn to supernatural plots and I prefer my romance front and center, whereas it seemed quite slow-burn throughout Season 1 (perhaps this is due to Chris's route in particular). However, the quality and amount of writing really impressed me enough to keep going. I'm sure the professional-looking UI also did its part to reel me in.
One of the most delightful parts of the game is the customization and flexibility. I love choices, and lots of them. They are one of the most important parts of interactive fiction for me. This game includes a shocking amount of choice. I felt as if I was getting a choice every other page, maybe. When given this much choice, a player really begins to feel like they are involved in and changing the story, which is a wonderful feeling. The customizable appearance, gender, romance and background options are great. I also enjoyed the little stats menu to the right, it makes me happy to see how my choices shape the character.
While Season 1 impressed me, Season 2 had me enamored. The characters were all likeable to the point that I cared deeply about cultivating my relationships in this game. I wanted to be friends with and side with everyone, while also trying to do the right thing or what I thought was safest. The story did a good job of making that hard at times. I felt like the stakes really picked up and some scenarios actually left me sweating about my choices and feeling guilty even after I put the game down. That sort of lingering emotion induced by a game is priceless, I think. It was hard, by the way, to put the game down. I was perpetually on the edge of my seat, always wondering what was coming next.
The romance is blooming in Season 2, which I appreciate greatly. I've only experienced Chris and Zillah's romantic routes, so I can only speak on those. The scenes are touching and sweet (or spicy) when they need to be, but not without complexity or drama to keep things fresh and interesting. Zillah is absolutely magnetic and hands down my favorite, I can't wait to see how Roe and his relationship develops further. Also, Zillah and Chris bickering is hilarious and thrilling.
Overall, such a fantastic experience. I'm highly anticipating Season 3. I know that the writer will make it worth it, though I feel like they've already spoiled me with how good the game is already. I wish them the best of luck with their work and all the happiness!