I noticed your interest for "Mystic Ville", AnnaMayToes.
I played through the intro and was ... ah ... flabbergasted.
May I ask: Why do you like it so much?
It's quirky, alright. About the potential - well ...
Sadly I played a lot of this VN, too, and over time I come to the conclussion that my standards rise a lot. Therefore "quirky" might not be enough to excite me anymore.
But may I ask again: What are the other two candidates for Top Three? If Altos can stand it that we discuss other games, too.