Great update, I think I found the true path and it was way more rewarding, thanks for the tip.
In this particular update (picking Tyler in Chapter IV), the "true path" or "best path" is:
Escape and beg Tyler
Get up and follow
Put on Latex
Start Posing (pick only the Pink poses)
Yes, desperately want
How long
Stop sucking and look up
Tyler approaches
Restrain
Yes (but he won't hold it against you if you leave the tub, I know watersports is not for everyone)