did you check the far back arrow in the market park? If I remember correctly that is where she is.
Viewing post in Hero's Harem Guild (NSFW +18) comments
I did, I've searched all every part of the market at midnight and she is nowhere to be found. shes still topless in her bed when I go to her room in guild house. is this something I need to find and click on or should it just happen when I get to the area shes in?
EDIT - Had to talk to jimmy to get the quest rolling I guess.