Very sorry you got stuck. Theres another one of those rock amulets hidden in the first floor of the lighthouse, its on that boat in the corner. Apparently we hid it to well since pretty much nobody was able to find it!
oh man, it was right there! I'm really glad I didn't rag on your game too much when it was really my fault. I'm glad I didn't reset my game.
I don't think you hid it too well, I think it's more of an issue of the players not knowing what to look for. I was looking right at it and couldn't see it for a few moments. I think sometimes games need to communicate how hard you need to look. Some games the critical items are basically handed to you, so you don't need to spend much time searching every corner of every room. Other games make you search out every item. Knowing which type of game you're playing helps set expectations.