A newbie? Aren't this your lucky day? I'll give you the best of the best out there that I've known of course. Let's start with Eternum, the undisputed king of the new gen AVN. If you enjoyed the simple confined and horny, you'd be blown away by the lore and adventure that awaits inside Eternum! Second is the arguably the best in the genre, Being a dik. Don't be fooled by it's title and think (this might just be a segs for the sake of segs trash) you couldn't be more wrong. If you ain't easily offended, love relationship drama, college bullsheets and just wanted to have a good time and think about the good ol days? Badik is your treat. Next is the new but underated underdog (or cat) story about a washed up volleyball ashwhole that got a second chance after a plot convenient character gave him a scholarship I'm exchange of rebuilding their university's f*ked up volleyball team. That's basically the premise but don't be fooled because I tell you, the WILDCATS are rising.
That's it for now, if you want more recommendations, just reply to my comment cause those are far from the only great ones. Play those three first if you want to fall in love with the genre.