Post by APS Games in Are these 2D Soccer Avatars optimized enough for your UI/Trading Card games? Need dev feedback on my workflow!

Viewing post in Are these 2D Soccer Avatars optimized enough for your UI/Trading Card games? Need dev feedback on my workflow!

Hey hironakamura! 🫂

Man, you really kept your promise, and I can't tell you how much I appreciate that! 😊 Honestly, your feedback feels less like just a critique and more like advice from an older brother or a true dev buddy. Thank you so much for the depth and honesty. ❤️

From a UI-heavy dev perspective, what you said about 'Consistency'—establishing a strict template, same canvas size, character scale, and a common ground line—completely opened my eyes. 🤯 I totally get it now; a developer should be able to swap assets without touching their UI layout at all. You're 100% right about the thumbnail, too. I'm updating the cover today to feature 3-4 characters large and clear so the product explains itself before anyone even reads the title. 🎨✨

And man, what you shared about your own experience with AI artwork... that genuinely touched my heart 🥺. It is really encouraging to know I'm not alone in facing that specific criticism. You're absolutely right—from now on, I won't hide it. I'm going to make the 'hand-cleaning' and consistency my actual value proposition with total transparency. 💪

I'm taking your advice to heart: I am definitely not rushing all 32 teams yet. I'm going to fix the technical issues Pixelkiln pointed out, build that one strict production template, improve the storefront, and then just test the pipeline with 2-4 teams. 🛠️

Thank you so much for taking time away from coding your own game to give me such harsh but genuine feedback! 🙏 You are genuinely an awesome mentor in this community. Get back to your code—I'm waiting to play and reclaim my #1 spot in your game! 🎮🔥

Cheers, brother! 🍻

Like Reply

hironakamura1 day ago(+1)

Brother, now you’re making me feel like I need to start charging for consulting 😂

Seriously though, I’m really happy the feedback helped. And I respect that you’re actually taking criticism, changing things and testing again — that’s exactly what I’m trying to do with my own game too.

We’re both building and learning as we go. So anytime you want my opinion, just ask. 🤝

And about that #1 spot… careful what you wish for 😂 I already have one criminal monopolist giving me enough trouble in my own game.

Cheers brother 🍻

Like Reply

APS Games1 day ago(+1)

Haha, the consulting invoice is definitely in the mail! 😂

Seriously, thank you so much, brother. Your feedback was a massive game-changer for me. As a beginner, learning how to properly format and test my sprites (instead of just uploading raw images) gave me a lot of confidence.

I will definitely take you up on that offer! I'm actually formatting a 'Halloween Ghost & Props Asset Pack' right now, so I might need your expert eyes on it soon. 🎃

Good luck dealing with that monopolist in your game! Crush him!

Cheers brother! 🍻

Like Reply

hironakamura17 hours ago(+1)

Haha, then keep working on that Halloween pack 😄 You might already have a future customer.

Once Gilded Dominion is fully launched, I want to run seasonal events — Halloween, autumn, Christmas and things like that. I’ll definitely need themed assets for those events.

So who knows… maybe one day I’ll be buying your packs instead of giving you free consulting 😂🍻

Like Reply

APS Games16 hours ago(+1)

Hey hironakamura, the wait is over! 🎃 The Ultimate Halloween Pack is finally ready and live on my itch.io profile.

I would be absolutely honored if you could be my very first visitor. Please take a look at my page and give me your completely honest feedback. If there is anything wrong, any technical issue, or anything at all that doesn't feel right, please tell me—I am ready to fix it right this second.

Since I am just starting my journey in this market, your words mean the world to me. Just one piece of advice or suggestion from an experienced dev like you can truly shape my future. Thank you so much for the amazing support! 🍻

Like Reply

hironakamura13 hours ago(+1)

Damn, you actually finished it already 😂 I told you I might need Halloween assets in the future and a few hours later you're back with a complete pack.

I had a look and I can already see you applied a lot of what we talked about. The free sample + premium version is a good idea, and the technical information is much clearer now.

One thing caught my attention though: your license says buyers can actually resell or redistribute the asset pack, even for a higher price. Are you sure you want that? 😅 If you're trying to build this into a real asset business, I'd think carefully about that part.

Otherwise, nice progress brother. You definitely don't waste time 😂

And like I said before — keep building these seasonal packs. If Gilded Dominion gets where I want it to go, Halloween, Christmas, autumn and other events will need assets every year. Who knows, maybe I'm looking at one of my future suppliers already. 🍻

Like Reply

APS Games5 hours ago

Man, I really appreciate you taking the time to look closely at my page!

First off, I want to clear up the speed thing haha. I definitely didn't build this whole pack in just a few hours! I have actually been grinding on these assets for a long time—cleaning up frames, fixing metadata, and applying all the workflow feedback you gave me earlier. Yesterday was just about putting the final touches and hitting publish. 😊

Regarding the license... you were absolutely right. To be completely honest and vulnerable with you, I come from a very tough financial background and I haven't made a single dollar online yet. I added that resale clause out of pure desperation, thinking it might attract quick buyers. But hearing it from an experienced dev like you made me realize it just looks unprofessional and hurts the trust I want to build. Your reality check was exactly what I needed. I have already removed it and updated the page to a standard commercial license.

Also, I noticed the 5-star rating you left on the page. I honestly don't have words to thank you enough. You didn't just give me free consulting; you actually supported my work when I needed that initial push the most.

I completely understand that you will need these assets later when your seasonal events for Gilded Dominion start. Just knowing that you are looking out for a struggling beginner like me gives me a lot of hope. Thank you for being a true mentor. 🙏

Like Reply