I think it may be bugged? I have the same issue. On the leftmost thing, you press button 1, then 2, then 3 to fill up the circle thingy, right? BUT... then what happens? Shouldn't I get a soul or something that I can sell? I get nothing, nothing changes. It uses the ingredients but I can't see anything going up when I complete, or find where I would sell something if I did have it?