I also voted tor the Comfy style, it reminds me most of how the game used to look. I am opposed to the Nosey style not because of the noses, I don't mind the noses much, my problem is with just how it looks in general. The original game's style and the Comfy style both look cute and wholesome, perfect for the wholesome scenes we all love to see in this game. The Nosey style looks too sexy and serious, and if most of the dialogue stays the same as in the original CK, I feel like there'd be a mismatch between, for example, Pixie's new angular edgy teen looking face, and the cute and silly dialogue coming out of her mouth in quite a few of the more lighthearted scenes. This game doesn't do serious often enough to justify making the entire art style look more serious like in the Nosey style, the same can be said for horror and the Steamy style, this game doesn't do horror enough to justify prioritizing making that look good. This game does wholesome often and well, and should prioritize making what it does often and well look as good as possible. Doesn't that just make the most sense?
Part of it is definitely nostalgia, though. I can't claim I have an unbiased opinion. I really want more people to vote for the Comfy style, I really want Comfy to win, because I miss my cute and comfy Corrupted Kingdoms. I miss it a lot. It's been too long. I want the game I fell in love with back.