I like the idea, but it felt a little too unclear about who actually fit the requirements vs who didn't. It was also a little too easy to not realize I had lost and it wasn't just giving me the same profile twice in a row, so maybe making the loss state a little clearer could be beneficial, especially because I didn't even realize the "what you're looking for" section changed!
Also one thing: the itch page, cover image, and game's start menu all have different names, which is a bit confusing.