well i don't know if it is affected by all of your choices along the story or just in this chapter but for me i chose that choice as well as the 1st one in the breakfast scene with her at the beginning of the chapter and i got the scene. For me i tend to hear for the sound cue which u get after a good choice after a series of chatting happens after u choosing something since i thought that was my cue i chose correctly and that helped me get all the scenes thus far
but for your case i don't know rly if u should trace all the way back to the rest of ur past choices with her or just the ones in this chapter