Post by werzaque in RPG Maker Asset Contest FAQ(English)

Viewing post in RPG Maker Asset Contest FAQ(English)

Also... I think it would be appreciated if you stated the reasons for this decision, as I see a number of enemies being submitted.

GotchaGotchaGames30 days ago(-2)

Thank you for your feedback.
While there were multiple submissions in the Enemies category, each entry was carefully reviewed based on our submission guidelines and selection criteria. Unfortunately, no entry was selected for an award. We sincerely appreciate everyone who submitted their work.

werzaque30 days ago (1 edit) (+4)

Wouldn’t it be polite to at least give a reason as to why NONE were chosen? It seems very odd to me that you are being so vague about this. Not good PR, in my opinion.

callmeDJ30 days ago(+4)

I agree. Considering that there were more than enough enemy graphics to pick a winner from, I think one of the eight or so entrants who submitted an enemy deserves to be acknowledged for being the best of the bunch.

werzaque28 days ago (1 edit)

Yeah not understanding it at all. I have been rereading the submission guidelines and although there are a couple that can be considered disqualified on those grounds (missing "assetcon_enemies" tag, or priced at 4 dollars), if that is the case they should say so. And even then there seem to be a handful that just are according to the submission guidelines.

werzaque8 days ago

Could you at the very least explain why all the entries were disqualified? I think you really owe to the participants to be more transparent.

GotchaGotchaGames7 days ago

Thank you for your feedback.
We would like to clarify that no winner being selected does not mean that all entries were disqualified. All eligible entries were reviewed as part of the judging process.
To ensure fairness to all participants, we do not disclose detailed judging information or evaluations of individual entries.
If you have any further questions, feedback, or suggestions, please contact us by email at pd-officialdlcen@gotchagotcha.jp

itch.io

Viewing post in RPG Maker Asset Contest FAQ(English)