Have you completed The Hunt with him? (Maybe twice; I'm not sure.)
Yes, and I did do it twice. Once before the werewolf thing, and twice after.
What's his current Like at? That may have something to do with it, or maybe it's connected with your relations to Hayden. I couldn't say for certain.
Bernard's is at 71 and Hayden's is at 86.
I couldn't guess, then, unless you accidentally already did it and skipped over it
