The Judge would say the Wretch is telling the truth. The Wretch is only seen as evil, not a liar. It's the same as the Puppet being seen as truthful to the Judge. Just think the Wretch as another Puppet.
Hey, thanks! I really appreciate you telling me that. I never made the connection that a Judge would see the Puppet as honest, as well (since, of course, the Puppet is honest). Another tool for the belt, you know? Thanks again!