Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(4 edits) (+3)(-1)

I'm posting this here because, honestly, this feels like one of the only places where feedback can be shared publicly without being behind a paywall.

I want to start by saying, I LOVE Eternum. The story, the characters, everything about it is amazing. It's genuinely one of the best visual novels I've played. That's why I feel the need to speak up instead of just sitting quietly. That said... the update schedule over these past years has been really frustrating. The jump from 0.8 to 0.9 took just a little over a year. While the update itself was nice, it didn't feel like it matched the wait or financial support coming in; it felt pretty short, in all honesty. With over 10,000 paying supporters and a team credited on the project, it feels reasonable to expect either more consistent updates or at least some explanation for the delays/increased development time. 

What makes it even harder is that this isn't the first time. It's been a pattern, ever-increasing stretches between updates, and very little public communication about why. When support keeps coming in month after month, but progress slows down, it starts to feel... unbalanced. No one is asking for perfection, but it's hard not to feel like our patience is being tested without acknowledgement. The silence doesn't help. Most of the discussion spaces are locked behind a paywall, so it's hard for any feedback, especially critical but respectful feedback, to reach the developer or community. That makes it feel like no one notices or cares, even if some of us may be quietly frustrated. 


To Other Players/Supporters

I'm not here to tell anyone how to spend their money. If you're happy with the update pace and the game, that's fine. I just think it's worth looking at the bigger picture. A year-long gap between updates, combined with so many people paying to support the project, is something worth talking about. Silence doesn't always mean there isn't an issue; sometimes, it just means no one realizes it or wants to be the first to say something.


To Caribdis (If You Read This)

This isn't an attack on you, and it isn't a demand for impossible output. I understand making a game like this does take time. That said, given the level of financial support and the credited team working on the project, it's hard to understand why progress has been so slow and why communication about delays is almost nonexistent. From the outside, it can easily look like the timeline is being stretched intentionally to keep support coming, which I'm sure isn't the impression you want to give. 

This is why I'm asking for accountability, either a clearer explanation for the delays or a faster development pace that reflects the support you're receiving. Supporters care about Eternum, I care about Eternum, and I think most of us just want reassurance that our trust and support are being respected. I'm sharing this in good faith, hoping it opens a conversation rather than being dismissed.



Final Notes

I want to emphasize that this isn't about negativity or entitlement. I'm sharing this because I GENUINELY care about Eternum, about the community, and about supporting creators responsibly.  Taking a moment to reflect on how support, communication, and development pace align benefits everyone: the developer, the community, and the longevity of the project. If nothing else, I hope this encourages more open discussion, whether it's about timelines, updates, or simply making sure the community feels heard. Constructive criticism and feedback go a long way toward building trust, and I think we all want the game to succeed in the best possible way.

(2 edits) (+1)(-1)

I wanted to write a comment like yours a while ago, but I never got around to it.

Because the game means something to me too, and I also think the development is going in the wrong direction. Many important points have already been mentioned in your comment, but I'd like to add a something to it


A little info about me

I'm a game developer myself, not in the adult games industry, but I think I can discussion in this topic because as a developer I have a different perspective on a game than a player.


Caribdis has reached the point where he has to decide whether he's doing all this just for the money or to write stories. In an itch comment, he said he wants to make more games after Eternum for as long as he can, or he also mentioned in an older comment about an OIALT rework if the community wants it. 

And if development continues like this, I don't think there will be another game after Eternum. Caribdis himself once said Eternum would have 12-14 chapters in total, and if the development time continues to increase like this with each update, Eternum will hit over 10 year total development time. Caribdis won't stay young forever. If he wants to tell more stories than just OIALT and Eternum, then he should change something.

Looking at the numbers on Patreon and how many people have subscribed to high-tiers, I'd say Eternum brings in around $50k USD or more per month without taxes.

With the resources he has through support, he could easily bring in a few more people. That would take a lot of work off his hands and significantly speed up development. I would seriously consider it if I were you, Caribdis, if you really want to continue making games.

Finding good and trustworthy developers isn't easy, I know, but I'm sure there are many talented young people out there who would be happy to help you with development.


Also to mention

I don't know what's going on in Caribdis's life, and there might be other reasons why development is taking so long. I don't want to accuse him, but being more open with the community is also a very important point.

At the end of the day, it's Caribdis's decision. If he's really only here for the money, he'll just continue as he is and extend development even further because his community supports him no matter how long an update takes. 

And if he's here to write stories and wants to keep making more games, he should think long term,  at some point, he'll no longer be able to create games like because he might get too old for stuff like that or other things happen in his life . And maybe then he'll regret wasting so much time on a single game. Having all that money but not having used it properly, but as I said, it's his own decision what he does with his future developer career.


I don't think Caribdis will read your comment here. Because after the comments on Eternum and OIALT's main page were removed, he stopped replying to any comments on itch.

If you really want the message to reach him, just buy the cheapest one-month subscription and comment in a chat where he'll actually see it and maybe even reply.

Love your comment, if the dev is in it for the money then the next game he makes will be with a program that Steam allows on their platform. Honey select has copyright issues which sucks.

Cari already said on Discord that he's sticking with HS2 for the third game so nah.

I was SO doumbdfounded re-clicking 'update post's like 5 times trying to guess what I'm doing wrong to not seeing any comments... Then I went for my old notifications, opened direct link from there - and got "404"(which finally explained things).
I also remember that at very first 0.9 update release there was theme and it was opened... I discussed there at which version DMCA took over and "AI" music replaced main one - to maybe keep original one(in case I still have that version) and not "update"(c)-nullify what I have.

- And now, trying to refresh my memory after chaotic months I had - even that is gone... I guess "checking up update" delays again for me, as I'm not sure where(and - if) I'll find that info again..

If someone reading this still remembers which exact version took the hit - please reply!
As was sharply pointed by poster above - when "you young and full of ambitions" you might overlook longer picture... This was not exactly my case - but I did had in mind idea to extract all original music from my game instance(in case I still have it) and replace it (either via direct files - or even redacting Python code!) in the game. Now[a lot happened over past 1.5 month...] I understand that I no longer have energy/time for that (at least - right now) - but I still want to have original music regardless of "conditions". I wont update my game for a while in case someone answers - so I can upload needed files if that happens(and hopefully someone else will manage to complete this "fix" - I know I was not the only one who disliked "ai" update).

p.s. I too hope update frequency will improve... Like if update got 2m earlier - I'd implemented even python-code full-swap by myself by now(which I bet hunderds of people would've liked).

try f95zone they may have the old version for download