the one thing i can think of is if you're redoing the earlier days and thus the rules for the potions havent been fully flushed out yet. Like the milk for skeletons rule comes a couple days after the milk for the bra of holding.
for #2 did the warrior have a yellow glowing weapon? at some point if people have yellow glowing weapons you're not supposed to use milk. then inflate potions take over that later.
inflate is always used when someone has a yellow glowing weapon. and ONLY the yellow ones. Blueberry is always and only used when the previous person didn't get ANY mixtures. e.g. warrior with a bow against gawkers. no boobs thus no jiggle, so next person after them, UNLESS THEY HAVE YELLOW GLOWING WEAPONS, gets the blueberry. The special ones (the three last potions) go in this priority Inflate over Blueberry, blueberry over [spoiler]