Man, I really like the absurdity of the character designs. Also, I think more games should let me just phase through buildings — like, why does every game have collisions in the first place? Really, think about it.
I just wish you guys had implemented some SFX. Any unfinished horror game has the potential to be an amazing surreal experience with proper sound design. There’s even a whole subgenre of horror games that consists of making unfinished or abandoned games/MMOs on purpose, and it’s easily one of my favorite experimental types of games.
Overall, as much as not being able to finish a game jam can feel demoralizing, I hope you guys focus on the positive and make another game — or even finish this one. You clearly show real talent when it comes to surreal illustration.
My suggestion would be to play more experimental games in this field, like the ones I mentioned above, as well as LSD Dream Emulator on the PS1, and then incorporate whatever you learn from them into your next project.