Thanks for playing! We considered having a "New Game +" mode where you could simulate the specific playthrough you wanted (eg. play as if this is the 2nd play), but we didn't end up getting to use the mechanic enough to really make it worthwhile.
Good point on signposting the memory reveal, especially that you would only get one click. I'd like to find an in-universe way to make that clearer.
Thanks for the feedback!