I love the concept of this game. But the girls feel like they are catering to incel's fantasies, not real women. Having them be open minded is required for the plot to work, but it feels like they go too far, and it's not believable. This feels a bit like a mind-control-rape with how much they are throwing themselves at our MC.
Evelyn for example is perfectly fine with the MC fucking every girl out there, but doesn't want to have anyone else herself? This makes no sense. I think the game would feel much more believable if she was talking about wanting to have the MC ride along in her mind while she fucked guys/girls, as well as her riding along in his when he fucked other girls. They would have an emotional bond holding them together and share experiences, instead of her being a vapid two dimensional person-shaped object only acting on the MC's whims. The scene where she's invited to meet her idols is a great example. Why the hell is she asking for permission there? If the MC denied her there, he would be a huge hypocrite and any sane girl would leave him on the spot.