Overall: ★★★★☆
Nice game but needed more time than 4 days
Creativity ★★★★★
The idea is great, theme fits perfectly and not the obvious way, love that you tried to handle semi-turn based battles + rhythm game, but it feels to me 4 days isn't enough time for polish such genre needs
Enjoyment★★★★☆
While I love the concept and see the potential for me it felt too prototypy to fully enjoy. Nor tactic nor rhythm aspect fully shines sadly and they also feel glued together not being a part of the same loop. I would probably tweak and enrich the core a little bit forward, for example introducing octaves with special effect, so that listening and understanding sound part is required for a success. Giving it strong 3/5 of enjoyment + bonus ★ for the enjoyment I got thinking of how great this game could become given enough time:D
Narrative ☆☆☆☆☆
Not rating it here
Artwork ★★★★☆
Great art, flame guy felt a bit out of place for this game but other than that good job!
Audio ★★★☆☆
To a game that sells itself as music game I have a higher standard:D While SFXs are great I think they need much more time to be tuned precisely, right now it feels like a fun idea not a core mechanic