Overall: ★★★★☆
If only it was a shop management simulator with ever rising number of ingridients:D
Creativity ★★★☆☆
The game fits the theme well, but the crucial aspect for me in rating is "Will the game be better or worse without this mechanic" and here I think the game would be pretty same with simple "Retry" or depleting points.
Enjoyment★★★★★
Loved it, great deduction game with cute art and nice dialogues. The only weak point for me is that any fail takes too much time even with fast-forward option, but besides that it was an enjoyable experience
Narrative ★★★★☆
Cannot call it a narrative driven game, but dialogues and the setting felt good to me, it was easy to immerse myself and not think about it from pure game mechanic perpective, good job!
Artwork ★★★★★
Art is gorgeous, UI is clean and intuitive, good job!
Audio ★★★★☆
BGM is nice and doesn't annoy even after 10 minutes. SFXs are clean and fit the game well, really nicely done!