Graphics: 5 - Really nice, coherent visuals! The character designs were simple, but clean and sharp. I also loved the little animations, weird enemies and the environments. Great job developing all these assets over such a short time period!
Sound: 4 - The tracks were catchy and memorable, suiting the game well. Other sound work was straightforward without much fanfare, but things weren't out of place or anything.
Story: 3 - An interesting choice of narrative that follows Harold as a Christ-like figure who gathers apostles and performs miracles while defying expectations. I quite liked the concept, it's an extremely clever take on the jam's conceit. The actual dialogue (outside of Lucius) is quite dry, functional but not offensive. The two endings weren't really a satisfying conclusion to the game but I did like the portrayal of the antagonist as little more than a bully first and foremost.
Comedy: 2 - The enemies made me smile! I'm not sure I understood the deal with Lucius - I didn't hate him though.
Gameplay: 2 - I think navigating the town is pretty neat, as well as the node map. The combat is quite pretty but mechanically very weak. ATB is a personal dislike of mine so I might be biased, but with the way you acquire resources the whole thing is broken open almost as soon as you start.
That said, the combat also doesn't waste your time and is over very quickly, so it was at the very least not painful.
Overall: 4 - A very good entry. The combat is a miss but the execution of everything else is decent to great. Good job!