Instead of deindexing and/or delisting games outright, I really wish Itch would put an overlay on affected games that describes the reasons for that specific game to be deindexed/delisted. I understand that would require quite a lot of work to implement, but I think it would dispel suspicions of nefarious blocking of LGTBQ+ content.
Given that many people talk about all aspects of LGTBQ+ life as inherently pornographic and harmful to children (e.g. two men kissing eachother), it’s easy for people (including me) to strongly suspect this has and will disproportionately affected LGTBQ+ projects and creators.