0.18 Data:
This time was much easier thanks to the Dungeon Codex, which will give the recipes of any potions you've acquired.
Instead of trying out every combination one by one, I just used the "Give all Potions" cheat and transcribed & sorted the data.
Body: Female - Violet, White, Pink
Body: Futa - Violet, White, Red
Body: Male - Violet, White, Cyan
Arms: Fiendish Arms - Black, Pink, Cyan
Body Cover: Fur - Black, Pink, Violet
Body Cover: Fur Moth - Black, Red, Orange
Body Cover: Fur Spotty - Black, White, Pink
Body Cover: Fur Wasp - Black, Violet, Pink
Body Cover: Scales - Black, Orange, Pink
Body Cover: Scaly Face - Black, Green, Red
Body Hair: Hairy - Green, Pink, White
Body Hair: Heart Shave - Orange, Cyan, Violet
Body Hair: Messy Strip - Orange, Cyan, Black
Body Hair: Shaved - Orange, White, Pink
Body Hair: Small Strip - Orange, Cyan, Green
Body Hair: Strip Shave - Orange, Cyan, Red
Body Shape: Average - Violet, Red, Pink
Body Shape: Built - Green, Orange, Red
Body Shape: Chubby - Violet, Red, Cyan
Body Shape: Fit - Violet, White, Green
Body Shape: Muscular - Violet, White, Orange
Body Shape: Petite - Green, Orange, Pink
Body Shape: Shortstack - Green, Orange, Cyan
Body Shape: Skinny - Violet, White, Black
Body Shape: Slender - Green, Orange, Violet
Breasts: Bolt On Breasts - Green, Red, Orange
Breasts: Flat Breasts - Violet, Red, White
Breasts: Huge Breasts - Violet, Orange, Pink
Breasts: Large Breasts - Violet, Red, Black
Breasts: Medium Breasts - Violet, Red, Green
Breasts: Perky Breasts - Green, Red, Violet
Breasts: Saggy Breasts - Green, Red, Black
Breasts: Small Breasts - Violet, Red, Orange
Brows: Cyclopean Brows - Black, Orange, Green
Brows: Fuzzy Brows - Orange, Red, Pink
Brows: No Brows - Green, Black, White
Brows: Pretty Brows - Red, Black, White
Brows: Spot Brows - Black, Red, Violet
Butt: Average Butt - Orange, Green, Cyan
Butt: Beefy Butt - Green, Violet, Pink
Butt: Big Butt - Green, White, Black
Butt: Bubble Butt - Violet, Orange, Green
Butt: Fit Butt - Green, White, Red
Butt: Heart Butt - Violet, Orange, Black
Butt: Huge Butt - Green, White, Cyan
Butt: Petite Butt - Orange, Violet, Cyan
Butt: Round Butt - Green, White, Violet
Butt: Wide Butt - Green, White, Orange
Butt Quirk: Firm Buttcheeks - Green, Violet, Cyan
Butt Quirk: Soft Buttcheeks - Green, Violet, White
Ears: Cat Ears - Black, Pink, Green
Ears: Deer Ears - Black, White, Red
Ears: Droopy Ears - Violet, Green, Black
Ears: Human Ears - Violet, Green, Red
Ears: Kobold Ears - Black, Cyan, Violet
Ears: Pointy Ears - Violet, Green, Orange
Ears: Rabbit Ears - Black, Cyan, Red
Ears: Siren Ears - Black, Orange, Violet
Ears: Wolf Ears - Black, Cyan, White
Eye Color: Black Eyes - Violet, Black, Pink
Eye Color: Blue Eyes - Red, Pink, White
Eye Color: Brown Eyes - Violet, Black, White
Eye Color: Copper Eyes - Red, Pink, Black
Eye Color: Gold Eyes - Violet, Black, Orange
Eye Color: Gray Eyes - Green, Pink, Red
Eye Color: Green Eyes - Violet, Black, Green
Eye Color: Light Blue Eyes - Red, Pink, Violet
Eye Color: Light Brown Eyes - Violet, Black, Red
Eye Color: Light Green Eyes - Red, Pink, Cyan
Eye Color: Purple Eyes - Red, Pink, Orange
Eye Color: Red Eyes - Red, Pink, Green
Eye Color: Silver Eyes - Violet, Black, Cyan
Eye Color: White Eyes - Black, Green, Pink
Eyes: Arachna Eyes - Green, Black, Cyan
Eyes: Beady Eyes - Orange, Red, White
Eyes: Cyclopean Eyes - Black, Orange, Red
Eyes: Dopey Eyes - Orange, Red, Cyan
Eyes: Insectoid Eyes - Black, Red, Cyan
Eyes: Pretty Eyes - Red, Black, Violet
Eyes: Sharp Eyes - Orange, Red, Violet
Eyes: Sly Eyes - Orange, Red, Green
Face Shape: Chubby Face - Green, Cyan, White
Face Shape: Gaunt Face - Green, Cyan, Red
Face Shape: Normal Face - Green, Cyan, Orange
Face Shape: Round Face - Green, Cyan, Violet
Face Shape: Square Face - Green, Cyan, Pink
Face Style: Cheek Scars - Red, Black, Pink
Face Style: Eye Scars - Red, Black, Cyan
Face Style: Face Paint 1 - Red, Green, Pink
Face Style: Face Paint 2 - Red, Green, Cyan
Face Style: Face Paint 3 - Red, Green, White
Face Style: Face Paint 4 - Red, Orange, Green
Face Style: Face Paint 5 - Red, Orange, Black
Face Style: Freckles A - Red, Orange, Violet
Face Style: Moles A - Red, Green, Violet
Face Style: Moles B - Red, Green, Orange
Face Style: Moles C - Red, Green, Black
Hair Color: Auburn Hair - Red, Cyan, Orange
Hair Color: Blonde Hair - Red, Cyan, Violet
Hair Color: Brown Hair - Red, Cyan, Black
Hair Color: Coral Hair - Green, Red, Cyan
Hair Color: Cyan Hair - Green, Violet, Black
Hair Color: Dark Blue Hair - Red, White, Cyan
Hair Color: Dark Hair - Red, Cyan, Pink
Hair Color: Light Brown Hair - Red, White, Pink
Hair Color: Light Green Hair - Green, Red, Pink
Hair Color: Pink Hair - Green, Violet, Orange
Hair Color: Red Hair - Red, Cyan, Green
Hair Color: Silver Hair - Red, Cyan, White
Hair Color: Violet Hair - Green, Red, White
Hair Color: Yellow Hair - Black, Red, Pink
Hairstyle: Bun and Bangs - Orange, Cyan, Pink
Hairstyle: Buzzcut - Orange, Green, Red
Hairstyle: Double Bun - Orange, Cyan, White
Hairstyle: Long Hair - Black, Green, White
Hairstyle: Long Hair and Bangs - Black, Green, Violet
Hairstyle: Long Ponytail - Orange, Pink, Cyan
Hairstyle: Medium Bob - Red, Black, Green
Hairstyle: Mush Bob - Orange, Pink, Red
Hairstyle: Short Bob - Orange, Pink, Green
Hairstyle: Short Ponytail - Orange, Pink, White
Hairstyle: Sideswept - Orange, Pink, Black
Hairstyle: Sideswept Ponytail - Orange, Pink, Violet
Hairstyle: Slickback - Orange, Green, White
Hairstyle: Undercut - Orange, Green, Violet
Horns: Deer Antlers - Black, White, Violet
Horns: Fiend Horns - Orange, White, Cyan
Horns: Hobgoblin Horns - Orange, Green, Black
Horns: Imp Horns - Green, Violet, Red
Horns: Kobold Horns - Black, Violet, Cyan
Horns: Moth Antennae - Black, Violet, Red
Horns: Wasp Antennae - Black, Violet, White
Mouth: Canine Mouth - Green, Orange, Black
Mouth: Fangs - Orange, Red, Black
Mouth: Feline Mouth - Green, Black, Pink
Mouth: Kobold Mouth - Black, White, Green
Mouth: Pretty Mouth - Red, Black, Orange
Mouth: Rodent Mouth - Black, White, Cyan
Mouth: Ruminant Mouth - Black, White, Orange
Mouth: Underbite - Orange, Green, Pink
Mouth: Zombie Mouth - Green, Pink, Black
Nipples: Large Nipples - Violet, Orange, Red
Nipples: Medium Nipples - Violet, Orange, White
Nipples: Puffy Nipples - Orange, Violet, Green
Nipples: Small Nipples - Violet, Orange, Cyan
Penis: Average Penis - Orange, Black, Red
Penis: Small Penis - Orange, Black, Green
Penis: Tiny Penis - Green, Pink, Cyan
Quirk: Arachna Skin - Green, Black, Orange
Quirk: Broad Shoulders - Green, Orange, White
Quirk: Large Nose - Green, White, Pink
Quirk: Moth Neck Fur - Black, Red, White
Quirk: Narrow Waist - Orange, Violet, Pink
Quirk: Slime Skin - Black, Green, Cyan
Quirk: Spider Arms - Black, Pink, White
Quirk: Tiny Nose - Green, Cyan, Black
Quirk: Wide Hips - Orange, White, Black
Quirk: Zombified Skin - Green, Pink, Violet
Sclera: Black Sclera - Orange, White, Green
Sclera: Black Void Sclera - Green, Black, Violet
Sclera: Bloodshot Sclera - Green, Pink, Orange
Sclera: White Sclera - Orange, White, Red
Skin: Bikini Tan - Orange, Violet, Red
Skin: Smooth Skin - Black, Green, Orange
Skin: Spotty Skin - Orange, Violet, Black
Skin: Swimsuit Tan - Orange, Violet, White
Skin Color: Almond Skin - Red, Violet, Pink
Skin Color: Ashen Skin - Red, White, Violet
Skin Color: Beastly White Skin - Black, Pink, Red
Skin Color: Chocolate Skin - Red, Violet, Cyan
Skin Color: Cinnamon Skin - Red, Orange, Cyan
Skin Color: Copper Skin - Red, Orange, White
Skin Color: Crimson Skin - Red, Orange, Pink
Skin Color: Dark Grey Skin - Green, Black, Red
Skin Color: Deep Blue Skin - Red, Violet, Green
Skin Color: Deep Green Skin - Red, Violet, White
Skin Color: Fair Skin - Red, White, Green
Skin Color: Light Blue Skin - Red, Violet, Black
Skin Color: Light Green Skin - Red, Violet, Orange
Skin Color: Olive Skin - Red, White, Black
Skin Color: Pale Skin - Red, White, Orange
Tail: Cat Tail - Black, Pink, Orange
Tail: Fiend Tail - Orange, White, Violet
Tail: Moth Abdomen - Black, Red, Green
Tail: Reptile Tail - Black, Cyan, Orange
Tail: Short Tail - Black, Cyan, Green
Tail: Siren Tail - Black, Orange, White
Tail: Wasp Abdomen - Black, Violet, Orange
Tail: Wolf Tail - Black, Cyan, Pink
Vagina: Innie Vagina - Violet, Green, Pink
Vagina: Normal Vagina - Violet, Green, White
Vagina: Outie Vagina - Violet, Green, Cyan
Voice: Deep Voice - Orange, Black, Cyan
Voice: Deeper Voice - Orange, Black, Pink
Voice: High Voice - Orange, Black, Violet
Voice: Soft Voice - Orange, Black, White
Wings: Moth Wings - Black, Orange, Cyan
Wings: Wasp Wings - Black, Violet, Green