Hey, do you happen to have priority active? Have you tried to use it for each different girl?
Ok I think I've figure out the issue since I started a new game from the beginning. When you start a game from the 0.89 option the event gallery and the story text do not sync up which leads to the wrong events being displayed. In the girls character section but the event gallery already has them unlocked. So that seems to soft lock things that aren't connected to the main story at least.