I love a TF magic fight, and having the mechanical effects so well matched to the flavor of the potions is really doing it for me! The clinking glass sounds are so juicy, and I love the art and the way the characters are put together. I keep restarting the first round until I get one that looks like me, thank you for the curly hair. Also gathering a witch polycule as one of the witches is such a cute and refreshing framing vs the usual harem building vibes.
Most of the criticisms I have are the same as what's already been said on the game page comments. But this is genuinely one of the games I'd most like to see expanded on in the future, because being able to more deliberately explore some of the mechanics absolutely would keep me coming back. Cowbell starter deck, I beg you.