We strongly believe that you have misunderstood our intent, no one here has said that the other versions have no right to exist or that your work is not good and your icons must be trashed, we respect everyone's work and everyone is free to do the whdloads as they see fit.
Simply, since you said that there is already a whdload version of this game (probably to diminish our work with no luck for you) we compared the version of Amiga France available on their official website (therefore WITHOUT your specific icon) with ours so that the developer and users can evaluate independently and decide respectively which version to publish on his site and download, obviously highlighting our strengths and your weaknesses since you have questioned our credibility and professionalism, and therefore being in a democracy we absolutely have the right of reply and we have done so by bringing concrete facts.
The objective data is clear: generic whdloads, even accompanied by your icons that are really nice even if not compatible with classic workbench systems, do not comply with the standards of official whdloads because obviously as you said the generic Kickstart and workbench slaves are applied to ALL games indiscriminately, while we create SPECIFIC slaves for EVERY single game, And this while requiring much more time and effort, they allow us to raise the quality of our whdloads exponentially.
Of course you and someone else might think differently, but in the end what matters is the judgment of the developers and the Amiga community in general, and I can assure you that most of the feedback we receive from both is very positive, for the rest as they say: to posterity the difficult sentence...
And this is the end, we will never replay to you anymore because it's only a waste of time, let's get back to work for our users, for developers and for the whole Amiga community