Odd, I have something almost the same and I don't know what is making it exotic instead... hmm...
Here are the setting just in case this helps:
Completely shaved, bigger eyes, small nose, small mouth, big lips, thin shoulders, tiny breasts, huge penis, and big hips.
(Did have a thought, it might be helpful to have the impressions in the library where it tells which items add to what look, though that's just a suggestion. Have a great day. :D)
Update: It's the penis size, huge=not a trap/femalish. Sad but makes sense.