Man, that puzzle was seriously annoying, especially since I stumbled into the right one once only to click win instead of lose to get the time right.
I'm just going to spoil the answer for others because it was beyond frustrating to play 'balance the books' type thing using irregular components.
Tongue x3, Poke(x1), Peek, Cheek x2, Shirt UP, Play, Lick, BJ, Skirt, Intentionally Lose ~x2?
It legitimately took me several hours...admittedly it was only ~30 min after I started writing stuff down instead of winging it, but omg did it feel super underwhelming when the last ending was broken anyways thanks to cache filling up! The girl was missing and I had to go through the recollection to see what the ending kind of looks like. I was honestly hoping for the main girl in more animations for the special ending but that's probs because by the time I reached it was completely desensitized to the game.