Hello GreyHornet54!
Thank you very much for trying my game and for giving me your opinion so thoroughly.
I will try to go step by step to answer your points, hoping that I won't leave anything out.
I do not have a Patreon or a Subscribestar, I'm not delusional to think there is enough content inside the game just yet to monetize it. Later? Yes, surely, since I want this to become my livelihood (which aren't big dreams if you ask me, currently my 8 hours job earns me 900ish $) but as of now, I accept no payment from anyone, because I don't feel like I should even expect it, but thank you very much for thinking this way, I really appreciate it.
"Second thing I know you're still developing the game, but something I noticed while playing the latest version is that if the MC tells his GF "It's up to you" when talking about if she should talk to Catharine and Lucy she gets mad, but it doesn't change the outcome with Catharine" -
Think of it like this: Both Catherine's and Lucy's bad ending need 3 points to achieve them. Whenever a choice appears to tell either Lucy or Catherine about what you or your GF saw, you earn one point towards that character. You can go 1-0, 0-1 or 1-1. To alter the scenes in between, while it was very much possible, not something I could focus on, I was happy I could put everything together to work as it should, because this was my first huge project. I will try to write scenes that differentiate even more throughout your choices in the future.
"Personally I would like it to be possible for the main character to be able to be corrupted and taken by the Futa as well otherwise it kind of feels like a wasted opportunity to me." - There are little signs, foreshadowing for this to happen in the current patch. No scenes, but a new character portrait at a certain scene, if you read everything carefully :-) To speak frankly, there are hints in this patch for Futa On Male content for the future.
"Third it felt like I had to try and choose the worst options to encourage the GF to stray at points and the worst she got to was 75 I think, then it jumped back up to 95 shortly after so I basically got no where." - Do not feel bad about this, right now there are no scenes tied to character relationships, but it will certainly need to be balanced, so one can raise or lower it to their heart's conent, right now, it was just another layer of test if it works well, changing some of the dialogues, for example.
To ALL of your ideas, thank you very much, I'd say a lot of them I already planned or in some form I planned and will be involved in the future updates. Once again, I appreciate you for sharing your opinion, thank you very much! :)
- CandySH