Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous.

• Assessor: Anthony O Donnell - Art Director @d3t The idea for the scene at the start was really interesting. The realistic interior contrasted against a stylised view didn't make it at the end. Polygon distribution was inconsistent. One clear example being the tyre where the rope had too much and the tyre not enough to define the curvature / smoothness of the tyre. It was good to see a stylised piece, relative to the reference the final pieces colours were very saturated with lighting creating a high contrast look. The references pieces chosen have a softer look with less strong contrast with in the scene. The Tomka example also utilises edited vertex normals on the grass or a solution in the shader which gives the grass a softer look when lit. This piece is interesting and worth pushing more to get closer to the initial images presented during the concept phase.