Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous.

• 1. Fun Factor (4/5) Engagement: The dark, immersive storyline surrounding Witch Queen Kessandria keeps players engrossed, with tension heightened through varied encounters. Pacing & Challenge: The quest maintains a balanced pace, with challenging encounters like the Witch’s Fist pushing strategic thinking without overwhelming the player. 2. Design (4/5) Polish: The hand-shaped fortress design is both symbolic and functional, showcasing thoughtful creativity. Logic & Flow: While innovative mechanics shine, some trap placements feel overly punitive without clear foreshadowing, interrupting the quest's flow. 3. Narrative (5/5) Immersion: Rich lore and dark fantasy elements are seamlessly woven into the HeroQuest universe, with memorable villains enhancing the eerie ambiance. Consistency: The dark themes and cursed relics are consistently portrayed, though additional background on the Witch Queen’s motives could deepen immersion. 4. Staying Power (4/5) Re-playability: Multiple paths, dynamic NPC behaviors, and branching consequences boost replay value. Accessibility: While exciting for veterans, complex mechanics like permanent stat changes may challenge newer players, slightly limiting accessibility. Final Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (4.25/5) Feedback: Strengths: Thematic consistency and atmospheric design, especially the fortress layout. Innovative mechanics (cursed items, dynamic NPCs) add depth. Areas for Improvement: Soften overly punishing traps with subtle hints or mitigations. Offer ways to counteract permanent stat changes for player satisfaction. Clarify room descriptions for smoother gameplay. Conclusion: Kaestis Diagorum - The Dread Gauntlet is a brilliantly crafted, dark adventure that introduces fresh mechanics while honoring HeroQuest’s roots. Its immersive lore, creative design, and engaging gameplay make it a standout fan-made quest.