Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous and shown in a random order.

• This quest has a great set-up and a really well designed map for heroes to explore in their pursuit of the tome - I really like the various paths and clever use of the boulder too! The best of luck!
• HeroQuest Fan-Made Quest Rating: The Lost Archives Final Rating: 3/5 1. Fun Factor (3.5/5) Engagement: The narrative hook is strong, with an exciting infiltration theme adding tactical depth. Sneaking through the citadel’s cellars offers a refreshing break from routine quests. Pacing & Challenge: The boulder mechanic introduces strategic planning, maintaining steady pacing. However, the anticlimactic revelation of an unreadable tome dampens the overall thrill. Feedback: The tactical elements are enjoyable, but adding more dynamic events or evolving challenges could enhance the excitement. 2. Design (3.5/5) Polish & Logic: The quest integrates well with HeroQuest’s mechanics, featuring logical map layouts with secret doors and environmental hazards like brittle floors. Flow: While the design is solid, certain static encounters (e.g., the stationary mummy) feel underwhelming, and linear paths limit exploration options. Feedback: Introducing alternative routes or interactive environments would improve flow and player agency. 3. Narrative (3/5) Immersion: The dark citadel and lost tome theme align well with HeroQuest’s lore, initially immersing players in a mysterious adventure. Consistency: The quest maintains thematic consistency, but the narrative payoff is lacking. The climax feels incomplete, leaving players unsatisfied with the unreadable tome. Feedback: Strengthen the story’s conclusion with a meaningful twist or reward to create a lasting impact. 4. Staying Power (2.5/5) Replayability: Limited variability, fixed treasure placements, and linear progression reduce replay value. The boulder mechanic adds some variation but isn’t enough to sustain long-term interest. Accessibility: The quest remains accessible due to its adherence to HeroQuest rules, but predictable encounters lessen the urge to replay. Feedback: Add branching paths, variable objectives, or evolving monster encounters to boost replayability. ⸻ Overall Feedback: "The Lost Archives" is a well-crafted quest with unique mechanics and a strong premise. With enhanced narrative closure, diversified encounters, and increased replay options, it could shine as a standout fan-made adventure.