Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous and shown in a random order.

• 1. Fun Factor (4.5/5): The incorporation of pinball-inspired mechanics, including the momentum feature and flipper doors, adds a unique and engaging twist. The unpredictable interactions create dynamic gameplay, offering both entertainment and challenge. However, the tilt mechanics can sometimes feel overly punitive, slightly diminishing the fun for less experienced players. 2. Design (4/5): The quest showcases polished and logical map design with strategic monster placements and interactive elements like pits and flipper doors. The flow of the quest is engaging, though the complexity of the new mechanics may be confusing for players unfamiliar with custom content. Clarifying specific rules would enhance overall design coherence. 3. Narrative (3.5/5): While the quest maintains a fantasy theme consistent with HeroQuest, the narrative is relatively light. The minimal integration with HeroQuest lore may disappoint players seeking rich storytelling. Strengthening the background story and connecting it to the broader HeroQuest universe could significantly improve immersion. 4. Staying Power (4/5): The variable outcomes from dice rolls, momentum shifts, and random monster cards offer decent replayability. Though some fixed elements may feel repetitive over time, the strategic resource management and unpredictability of mechanics keep the quest fresh. Accessibility is moderate due to the learning curve associated with new rules. Overall Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5) Feedback for the Quest Creator: What We Enjoyed: Innovative mechanics, particularly the momentum feature, add creativity and excitement. Dynamic map design with interactive elements enhances tactical gameplay. Areas for Improvement: Strengthen the narrative to deepen player immersion. Balance tilt mechanics to reduce potential frustration. Clarify complex rules, especially around momentum interactions, for easier understanding. Summary: Tower of the Argent Moon is an inventive and engaging fan quest that breathes fresh life into HeroQuest through creative mechanics. While it diverges from traditional themes and could benefit from stronger lore integration, it offers a memorable and fun experience for both new and seasoned players.
• I really like the momentum/tilt ideas in this quest, and the fact that the Zargon player gets to take their turns differently too. The way the quest works introduces good grounds for replaying the quest - great work and good luck!