Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous and shown in a random order.

• A hugely ambitious quest that truly mixes up the mechanics and approaches to a standard HQ quest - well done!
• Criteria Ratings (Out of 5): Fun Factor: 4.5/5 The quest delivers an engaging experience with a high-stakes narrative centered around saving the King. The incorporation of dynamic elements like the rolling boulder adds tension and excitement. The pacing is well-maintained, keeping players invested throughout. Minor scripted events slightly limit player agency, which could affect repeated enjoyment. Design: 4/5 The quest showcases polished map layouts with logical flow and thematic consistency. Innovative mechanics like the boulder trap and statue puzzles enhance the gameplay. However, some mechanics would benefit from clearer explanations, and certain areas may feel overly linear, slightly impacting strategic flexibility. Narrative: 5/5 Strong integration with HeroQuest lore, featuring a compelling siege narrative filled with urgency and purpose. The quest’s story progression is effective, creating a satisfying arc. Some scripted outcomes could be balanced with more player-driven developments to heighten immersion. Staying Power: 4/5 Replayability is solid due to variable monster placements and strategic decisions. Adding more optional objectives or branching paths could enhance this further. Accessibility is commendable, though complex mechanics might require additional clarity for new players. Final Score: 17/20 Feedback: What Worked Well: The high-stakes mission adds excitement and urgency. Unique mechanics like the rolling boulder and statue puzzle offer fresh challenges. Strong thematic consistency with HeroQuest lore. Areas for Improvement: Clarify mechanics such as boulder movement and statue interactions for smoother gameplay. Introduce more enemy diversity and optional paths to boost replayability. Balance the early difficulty curve to ensure fair challenge across all stages. Overall, this fan-made quest is a thrilling and creative addition to the HeroQuest universe, with just a few tweaks needed to refine the experience.